September 23, 2020 4 min read


Are you in the market for a mattress in the Cincinnati, Ohio area? Perhaps your old mattress is in dire need of replacement. Maybe you are finally at a stage in life where you can invest in a higher quality mattress. Now that you are ready to buy, where should you be shopping?

If you aren’t shopping at a reputable mattress dealer, there are several problems that you could encounter. Problems with your mattress purchase can range from Pricing Issues to sanitation concerns, and finding a reputable store should be your biggest priority.

You may be buying a used mattress that has been repaired and resold. You might also be purchasing a used mattress that hasn’t been cleaned and sanitized correctly. You might not be getting the Cheapest Price for your purchase.

At Furniture Fair, we’ve been selling mattresses for over 50 years, and we know our stuff when it comes to the mattress industry. We continuously compare quality, pricing, and construction to ensure that we can compete with the best mattress retailers.

We want you to get the best possible mattress, and in order for you to do that we want to make sure that you have the best knowledge on the products that you are looking for.

To give you the best shopping experience when looking for a new mattress, we’ve done our research and narrowed down the five best mattress stores in the Cincinnati, Ohio area. If you can’t find the right mattress at Furniture Fair using our BedMatch System, you are sure to find it at one of these locations.

Founded in 1988, The Original Mattress Factory is a business designed to eliminate markups, gimmicky sales, and third party manufacturing. The Original Mattress Factory does not offer monthly promotions, as they believe that their prices are the best for the products they offer.

Local factories in the USA service all of their 113 stores, and they take pride in manufacturing mattresses that are free of middle management and extra steps in the supply chain.

Every mattress sold by The Original Mattress Factory is part of their in-house brand, so if you are looking for other name brands, you will not find them at The Original Mattress Factory. However, The Original Mattress Factory offers a full range of mattresses and box springs in the same categories available at other name brands.

If you want a flat price for a good product with no gimmicks, check out The Original Mattress Factory.

Mattress Firm has been in business for 90 years and features top brands like Tempur-Pedic, Sealy, Beautyrest, Purple, Serta, Sleepy’s, and more. With over 2,000 stores in 49 states, Mattress Firm is the nation’s largest mattress retailer.

Mattress Firm usually offers a 3-hour delivery window, and even delivers on Sundays. Mattress Firm also provides complete setup and removal of your old mattress.

Mattress Firm focuses on creating a unique shopping experience for the customer with a large selection of quality, brand name bedding products, competitive pricing, and knowledgeable sales associates.

If you are looking for competitive prices and a large selection of name brand mattresses with convenient delivery options, consider visiting Mattress Firm.

Opened in 1983, Sleep Outfitters now has 100 locations in Alabama, Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, Tennessee, and their original site in West Virginia. They have recently taken over the store locations formerly known as Mattress King and Mattress Warehouse.

Sleep Outfitters offers leading bedding name brands such as Sealy, Stearns & Foster, and Tempur-Pedic. Sleep Outfitters prides itself on providing a complete sleep solution, including the mattress, foundation, pillows, protector, and even sheets that are right for your specific body type and needs.

Sleep Outfitters focuses on the quality of sleep that you need. If you are looking to get a custom setup from the mattress to the pillowcases, Sleep Outfitters is an option you should consider.

American Freight was founded in 1994 and combined with Sears Outlet in 2020 to offer mattresses and appliances at discount rates.

Today, American Freight operates over 300 stores in 40 states across the United States and Puerto Rico.

American Freight is known for the “take it home today” message and usually offers same-day delivery on all in-stock items. In addition to delivery, American Freight provides payment plan options for every customer.

American Freight offers a wide selection of name-brand mattresses at discount prices. If you are looking for a deal on a name brand mattress that you want to be delivered today, then American Freight might be an excellent option to consider.

While mattresses might not be the first thing you think of when you hear the name Big Lots, the company has been making strides in the furniture and mattress retail industry. Big Lots is a discount retailer that offers name brand products at a discount on the original price.

Big Lots offers multiple sizes and styles of mattresses from name brands like Serta and Sealy. While the selection may not be as broad as other mattress retailers on this list, the prices that they offer are discounted from their original retail price.

If you are looking for a decent selection of mattresses at discount price points, stop by your local Big Lots and compare prices on the mattress options available.


Now that you’ve read this list of best mattress stores in Cincinnati, Ohio, You are ready to find the best deal on a new mattress. If your search for a mattress doesn’t end at Furniture Fair, you will now be equipped with the best places to shop for a mattress.

If you are in the market for a new mattress, consider Furniture Fair. We carry brand name mattresses like Beautyrest, Tempur-pedic, Kingsdown, Serta, Sealy, and Nectar.

We offer mattresses at every price point, and we can scientifically determine the best mattress for you using our BedMatch System. We offer many delivery options, including our newCurbside Shipping option. If you need a mattress, we have options for you.

Download The Complete Mattress Buyer's Guide

Buying a mattress is no small decision.
The Mattress Buyer's Guide will help you
learn more about mattresses and
prepare you to find the perfect mattress.